news from jawapos Another news about Taufik's withdrawal... Unfortunately, it is in Indonesian again... PBSI Hanya Bisa Pasrah JAKARTA - Jangan bilang dulu kebangkitan prestasi bulu tangkis tanah air. Jangankan untuk kembali disegani negara-negara lain, PB PBSI yang menjadi ujung tombak pembinaan bulu tangkis tanah air saja kini sudah tidak memiliki kewibawaan di mata para pemain pelatnas. Kasus mogok Taufik Hidayat untuk tampil di All England Super Series pada 6-11 Maret nanti adalah salah satu buah dari minimnya wibawa organisasi yang dipimpin Sutiyoso tersebut. Sebagaimana yang disampaikan Taufik pada media-media nasional, aksi mogok tersebut disebabkan ketidakpuasannya dengan keputusan PB PBSI. Ini terkait keikutsertaan beberapa pemain pelatnas dalam satu turnamen di Papua Desember lalu yang sebenarnya dilarang PB PBSI. Atas kejadian tersebut, PB PBSI menjatuhkan sanksi berupa larangan tampil di Swiss Super Series. Namun, menurut Taufik, sanksi yang tepat adalah larangan tampil di All England Super Series. Dengan alasan sanksi yang tidak tegas itulah, juara Olimpiade Athena 2004 tersebut mogok. Atas pemogokan tersebut, PB PBSI hanya bisa pasrah. Denda sebesar USD 250 harus dibayarkan karena kejadian tersebut. Lebih lanjut, para pemain terbaik dunia ke depan bisa saja enggan bermain di Indonesia jika yang dikirimkan pelatnas bukan pemain terbaik. Atas kondisi tersebut, PB PBSI hanya bisa pasrah. "Saya tidak bisa menyalahkan Taufik. Tapi, kalau alasannya kami tidak tegas dalam memberikan sanksi, kami telah memberi hukuman berupa skorsing di Swiss Super Series," kata Lius ketika dihubungi Jawa Pos tadi malam. Markis Kido, Luluk Hadiyanto, Alven Yulianto, dan Flandy Limpele, adalah beberapa pemain senior yang terhukum. Menurut Lius, keputusan mereka untuk tampil di Papua adalah tindakan kekanak-kanakan. Sebagai pemain nasional, mereka seharusnya mengerti dengan posisi mereka sebagai pemain pelatnas. "Sebelum mereka berangkat saya sudah berbicara banyak, tapi mereka tidak mengindahkan. Beberapa pengurus Pengda PBSI Papua juga terus memaksakan diri, meminjam pemain yang memiliki klub," papar Lius. Terpisah, Staf Ahli PB PBSI, MF Siregar, menyatakan bahwa hukuman yang diberikan pada pemain yang tampil di Papua sebenarnya sudah sesuai dengan aturan. "Kalau Taufik menuntut hukuman lebih cepat ya tidak bisa, karena itu skorsing baru di Swiss Super Series. Hukuman itu harus dibicarakan di antara para pengurus," jelas Opung, sapaan karib MF Siregar. Apa pun, kepergian beberapa pemain pelatnas ke Papua, kemudian aksi mogok Taufik, menunjukkan PB PBSI terus kehilangan kewibawaannya. Kalau pemain yang berangkat ke Papau atau Taufik memang bersalah, mereka seharusnya dihukum seberat-beratnya. Jangan karena mereka masih dibutuhkan untuk meraih gelar juara, kemudian bisa berbuat sesukanya. Kalau dibiarkan berlarut, kondisi tersebut bisa membuat pemain-pemain muda ikut tidak segan pada pengurus. Pada akhirnya, bulu tangkis tanah air akan makin terpuruk. (ang)
^^OK, time for...^^ ..another round of a different version translation job ..Calling indra, babonimut, DoublesPlayer, Krisna or others/anyone else..thanks in advance!.. Btw, here's the link: http://jawapos.com/index.php?act=detail_c&id=273725
I can assure you he has . Can't supply you with link though. I'm too lazy, you'll just have to trust me .
completly besides the point... you said Taufik wins if he wants to...and somebody was fast enough to mention the WC06... taufik isn't unbeatable, that's the plain and simple truth...sorry mate..
Mate.. it is not only Taufik who suffers... we're all indonesian fans.. will be most suffer not to see him playing in AE... :crying::crying::crying::crying::crying::crying: wizzy
Wei, it's not Hendra Setiawan, but Rendra Wijaya who went to Papua! Of course, if Markis Kido doesn't go to AE, Hendra Setiawan won't go either.
Actually I have expected this kind of issue. A player "boycott" and the sport association can do nothing. In the past we won't hear this issue. Every player was waiting for the phone call from the association to represent his country. He/She was very happy, it was a honour to represent his/her country. At present, not anymore. Honour is on the second place. In the first place is ....... yes.... money and politic. There are some players (football, tennis, basketball, badminton ....) who don't want to represent their country. Even for the big event like Would cup, Olympic games, Thomas/Uber cup, Davis/Fed cup, and so on..), because their association/country just give them a little bonus. When I red this thread, a BF'er said that the 7 players who went to Papua are paid with big money. Taufik didn't go, because he obeyed PBSI, but the 7 didn't. The 7 earned money, Taufik didn't. Then Taufik boycott, because....... money. PBSI give a punishment but very late, it seems that PBSI doubt to take a decision, why....., because .... politic. I said doubt, because the 7 players are very important for PBSI to get some titles in SuperSerie. PBSI didn't expect the reaction from Taufik. But now ........... What should PBSI does is: Punish the player who don't follow its rule, no matter who he/she is. PBSI has to show its power and not be controlled by the player, no matter who he/she is. I can understand that PBSI is afraid losing its best players, because PBSI has not many players anymore. PBSI try to keep its best players by listening to their request. PBSI say almost "YES" to all the request. I am also "agree" with Taufik. PBSI has to consistent in its words. If we go back to 10 year ago, this kind of situation won't be happened. At that time, PBSI had so many best players. PBSI was not afraid losing its players. Every players would do their best for their country. They trained hard and serious, because if they didn't play good enough, they had to forget the next tournament. They won't complain, because 'complain' didn't exist in their dictionary. In this situation, both Taufik and PBSI are right and also not right. Taufik is right, because he obeyed PBSI. Taufik doesn't right, because he "blackmail" PBSI. PBSI is right, because the 7 must be punished. PBSI doesn't right, because it let the player take the control. It means that PBSI has no power and doesn't consistent.
Indra.. mungkin lo betul... I think he is going to KLRC.. since in their website.. they telling that Taufik is coming to join them.. We as Indonesian really don't know what would be happen if Taufik join with KLRC and which country that he will represent then... wizzy
Off topic-Hmmm...so.. (i know that's an assumption) if he does leave Pelatnas and play somewhere else(like he tried to do earlier), will PBSI chase & ask him to come back all over again??..or will they let him go, for good, this time around??..And if PBSI ask him to come back, will he accept their invitation? or will he say, "Thanks but no thanks"??..
I don't think u guys should worry, even if Taufik joins KLRC, he will still represent Indonesia. KLRC has no objections of Taufik bringing his coach along too. Even now, KLRC's current pool of talent comes from BAM national discards/forced retirees and some from overseas. KLRC's setup is unique, the objective is to give out-of-favour players (who probably was not given a chance by their respective national associations) a new lease of life in the sport they love. In this case KLRC is not bound by any national association, not even BAM. Some players, like Lee Tsuen Seng and Sairul Amar Ayob, do better under KLRC than BAM.
this whole thing is a charade. On the surface TH's action may look like principle based but i'm sure if pbsi offered money that TH didn't get for obeying pbsi by not going to papua, i'm sure this charade would end.
Off topic-Hmm... ...if he goes & plays for KLRC, under what term(s), do you think, he will leave Pelatnas/National team??..if PBSI stand steadfast on what they "believe", do you think after what had transpired recently, he will come back and play for INA again??..
Off topic-That's interesting...so.. ...IF that actually happens, it essentially means that, once again, PBSI has "bend over backwards" and "smooch Taufik's feet" & treat him like "INA's Golden Boy" ...is that what's gonna happen this time around??..hmm
Well, KLRC players can play for their country, can't they? As long as KLRC registers them for tournaments, that is. No need to go thru PBSI or BAM for that matter.
Off topic-Sure... ...but i was referring more to the point of, will Taufik come back and play for INA, *under* PBSI's/Pelatnas' "authorization"??..Sure, he might still be wearing his jerzee with the name "Indonesia" on the back, for say Open tourneys(like other ex-Pelatnas players who are still competing) but will he still play for INA in the team events, ie. Thomas Cup or Sudirman Cup or Olympics/WC??..
