Would you boo at court officals when they make terrible line calls?

chris-ccc

chris-ccc

Regular Member
.
As a spectator at a tournament, would you boo (to show contempt, scorn, or disapproval) at court officals when they make terrible line calls?

I would; Just to wake them up. :):):)

Have a look at this video (from ye333);

[video=youtube;MCdUgLuRTF8]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCdUgLuRTF8&feature=related[/video]

:o:o:o
.
 
The reason umpires can now overrule is to combat this kind of situation.

I have a question for you: Have you ever sat on a line, or in the umpires chair?
 
Well umpires have always had the possibility to combat things like this, it was just a bit harder before.
Since you had to convince the referee to replace the line judge, which you still have the possibility to do.
But it is no easy task ;)

/Krysser
 
madbad said:
What's more hilarious is the reaction of the commentators to how far out the bird was during the slo-mo replay. They were trying so hard not to burst a lung.

I would advocate public stoning to teach such officials a lesson :p
Click to expand...

i suggest lining them up at the net and do a public shuttlecock execution.
 
Have you ever sat on a line, or in the umpires chair?

serviceover said:
The reason umpires can now overrule is to combat this kind of situation.

I have a question for you: Have you ever sat on a line, or in the umpires chair?
Click to expand...
.
Yes, I have; Many, many times. :):):)

I would say that it is not an easy job to do when I am feeling tired and wanting to leave the chair (to wake up with a cup of coffee before I return to such a sedentary job).
:):):)
.
 
I was also surprised that the commentators needed a slow-motion replay

madbad said:
What's more hilarious is the reaction of the commentators to how far out the bird was during the slo-mo replay. They were trying so hard not to burst a lung.

I would advocate public stoning to teach such officials a lesson :p
Click to expand...
.
I was also surprised that the commentators needed a slow-motion replay when the shuttlecock hit the floor so far out from the court.
.
 
A public shuttlecock execution?

kwun said:
i suggest lining them up at the net and do a public shuttlecock execution.
Click to expand...
.
Hahaha...... A public shuttlecock execution? :p:p:p

It would be cruel, but then it could be quite an entertainment for spectators at the venue.
:):):)
.
 
chris-ccc said:
.
I was also surprised that the commentators needed a slow-motion replay when the shuttlecock hit the floor so far out from the court.
.
Click to expand...

I think the commentators were so stunned they had to do a double take. You could hear in their voices and sarcastic laughs that they couldn't believe such a call had been made.
 
You could hear in their voices and sarcastic laughs that they couldn't believe it

madbad said:
I think the commentators were so stunned they had to do a double take. You could hear in their voices and sarcastic laughs that they couldn't believe such a call had been made.
Click to expand...
.
So...... You can understand Cantonese; like kwun does. :D:D:D
.
 
i think the commentator did a good job. one of them immediately noticed that bad call, commented on it, and then really burst into laughter on the replay. and after that, calmly says the umpire correctly overruled the call.
 
I wouldn't boo them, but I would definately make a point of giving them an evil glare or something. You never know they might be generous on the next point for you, or not.
I would never criticise them if they got a very tight linecall wrong, especially down the side tramlines on a fast smash.
 
If it's OUT, it's OUT

Andy05 said:
I wouldn't boo them, but I would definately make a point of giving them an evil glare or something. You never know they might be generous on the next point for you, or not.

I would never criticise them if they got a very tight linecall wrong, especially down the side tramlines on a fast smash.
Click to expand...
.
I would disagree. :):):)

If it's OUT, it's OUT.

And if it's IN, it's IN.

I would hope that line judge would not call the next shot IN if it was OUT (in order to correct his previous mistake).
:D:D:D
.
 
It's Korean Open and the line call is in favour of the Koreans. What do you expect? ;)

I've seen line judges replaced before. Is there a guideline for it? I would think two bad calls needs a replacement linesman.
 
Same exclamation as commentators on watching the replay ; "Waaaah'.

Isn't there a rule nowadays that all court officials must be neutral or is it just for umpires and service judges?
 
I would think two bad calls needs a replacement linesman

Cheung said:
It's Korean Open and the line call is in favour of the Koreans. What do you expect? ;)

I've seen line judges replaced before. Is there a guideline for it? I would think two bad calls needs a replacement linesman.
Click to expand...
.
I would agree that "two bad calls needs a replacement linesman".

That's why we should boo to make the tournament referee aware of what we spectators think. I was surprised that the INA players accepted it with a smile.
;););)
.
 
chris-ccc said:
.
I would agree that "two bad calls needs a replacement linesman".

That's why we should boo to make the tournament referee aware of what we spectators think. I was surprised that the INA players accepted it with a smile.
;););)
.
Click to expand...

I think that the INA players calm reaction was due to the quick over rule by the umpire. Of course as someone who watched the boxing at the 1988 Olymics and the 2002 Soccer World Cup. This isn't really surprising to me.
 
chris-ccc said:
.
I would disagree. :):):)

If it's OUT, it's OUT.

And if it's IN, it's IN.

I would hope that line judge would not call the next shot IN if it was OUT (in order to correct his previous mistake).
:D:D:D
.
Click to expand...
Yeah, but if it is a very close call, the sort of ones where when I am playing I genuinely don't know and I offer my opponent the call because I honestly don't know, they might give it your way.
I too would hope the line judge is always 100% correct, but we are humans, we make massive errors. Showing your dissapointment in the linejudge may make their next error in your favour.
 
Andy, the Korean linesmen are well known for "massive errors" on a more frequent basis in favour of Korean players.

Just off hand

Asian Games in Korea way back - forgot which year - Taufik and Indonesian team nearly resigned in protest. IBF officials eventually had to stand behind the linesmen to validate the linecalls.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top