The linesman is worse

kobe77sg said:
Yup I agree that the linesmen in thiw WC is poor. as the linesmen are mostly local, you can't expect the linesemen to bee god as how many people play badminton in Spain or how many badminton tournament held there. There is the disavantadge when big tournament held in this country.

I feel that IBF also unfair as spain has host the WC2001 in sevilla and WC2006 in MAdrid. Spain already host two WC in 5 years .
Click to expand...

correct me if I am wrong, I saw the picture from the Star (Malaysian Newspaper), most of the linesmen are the old man (above 50 years old)...........why ? Is it because of this reason...sorry no offence to the old man
 
Last edited:
if i am not mistaken the equietment is aready invented but is not approve yet
i am not that sure about it but just some recall from memory :P
i want the dvd , how do u send me ???
 
nomination of linesmen and umpire for WC

weeyet said:
I just wanna ask about this...

What's the IBF requirement when they called/recruited this WC's linesmen and umpires?
Do they have enough experience/qualification to duty in the WC?
I remember as for the football world cup, the selection requirement for the linesmen and referee is quite tough
Click to expand...

There are very strict regulation for nomination of umpires and linejudges for IBF events. Umpires have several grades from regional to national to international to continental to IBF. Every part has several grades too. To be umpire on WC has to be IBF grade with a lot of experiences and a lot of exams. For linejudges it is a little bit different. They apply as a volunteers but they also have to proof their experiences. On tournaments like WC or Olympic Games qiute often as a linejudges selected from umpires of continental grade.
 
Human make mistakes by their judgment.
i always felt that certain technology should be used at those important tournments.
 
baihaki_as said:
OMG, LCW get two bad calls in QF and LHI get three bad calls all happen in the game they lost against BCL, it made badminton not interesting again especially in wc, too many conspirancy , ibf should change the way or they'll fail to make badminton popular
Click to expand...
I can´t understand why a lot of people think that it is conspiracy, war between Asia and Europe etc. I was witness few times that player was complaining about linecall (I was sitting behind linejudge), player saw out and it was 10 cm in. Why when player is not playing well is blaiming linejudges for bad call, service judges for faulting them (or not faulting oppeonents) or umpire didn´t do that, did that etc. Isn´t it now that Asians are blaiming Europe because european players are getting closer to them and Asia is not anymore 5 steps in front of Europe but only 2 steps ? Please, don´t take it as a rasism or something like that, but think about that.
 
Excuse me but maybe not even half of linesmen were locals. In Europe is group of linejudges travelling to all major events (European Championship, prelims of Thomas and Uber Cups, etc) and most of them are experienced umpires that they don´t have grade to participate on WC as umpire (it takes long time to become IBF umpire to be selected to WC - at least 10 year with at least 200 matches a year). Do you think it is not experienced enough ?
 
WBF should seriously start using video replay ...
In my opinion it won't replace the role of the umpire but it will just help hm to make the game more fair .. I just saw a documentary abt that .. the main problem is that it costs a lot T_T
 
Its gambling, and its all about match fixing. Maybe its involve the IBF official as well. Asia vs Europe conspiracy is just an excuse. Yes, we never heard of this, but it doesn't mean that it does not exist. ..
 
Syaoran_Style said:
WBF should seriously start using video replay ...
In my opinion it won't replace the role of the umpire but it will just help them to make the game more fair .. I just saw a documentary abt that .. the main problem is that it costs a lot T_T
Click to expand...

:crying: I know :crying: But it will help the games a lot more. Money is very important :crying: :(
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top