Shin Baek Cheol

Would BKA really send Ko to the olympics though? After he filed a lawsuit against them? :P
If it's between sending them or sending no one I'm pretty sure they'd send them, after all the medal rankings don't care if you're in your sport's national team or not...
 
Would BKA really send Ko to the olympics though? After he filed a lawsuit against them? :p
that's a very good ?'n... it's hard to answer without knowing the internal politics of kba.

is kba prone to the habits of cba (china), bam (malaysia), bai (india) and other gov't backed federations? i suppose we'll soon find out.
 
If it's between sending them or sending no one I'm pretty sure they'd send them, after all the medal rankings don't care if you're in your sport's national team or not...
That's a good point. Perhaps if it were between sending Ko/Shin - or even Kim/Kim if they do well between now and April - and sending no one, they might. However, for that to happen, I think you'd have to have Choi/Seo out of the running. As it is now, there are no pairs from Africa or Oceania even in the top 80, so the BKA could easily pass over Ko/Shin and Choi/Seo would still be comfortably within the first 16 pairs to qualify. That could change if they are overtaken by a Thai pair or if the top 8 again has two TPE or DEN pairs in addition to two from Japan, China, and Indonesia.
 
Korean's have always been excellent at MD. To have no one in top 10 rankings in the present scenario is a fact that is hard to swallow. I just hope Ko/Shin make it to the top 10 (i think they are 16, after JAPAN OPEN) real soon and then motivate their other Korean counterparts to take up the MD discipline seriously.
 
I think Ko wouldn't be any fitter if he trained with the team, he's a real work horse from what I know :D
I really disagree on your statement about Koo, and Goh/Tan. I think Koo achieved exactly what he deserved, he was just too lazy, even as early as 2010...and while his style of play looks spectacular, it doesn't always pay off to go for the creative hard shot instead of the basic one. I don't think he ever was as good as LYD, Setiawan or Cai tbh.
Goh/Tan must be one of the pairs with the fewest career achievements that won OG silver. The saving grace is that the Bronze medal from the same games is completely forgettable and never achieved anything at all, and they're great in contrast :D
2016 games sure were the games of upsets, though. Half the favorites didn't make the playoffs, let alone finals or Gold.

i) Training with the national team doesn't necessarily have to mean that it is only fitness. Match practise, analyzing tactics of opponents using a specialized coach, not bothering about sponsor travel, so many things!! As far is fitness is concerned Ko is surely a great workhorse, as he played XD and MD simultaenously and maintained his rankings so so well.

ii) Absolutely agree on the Koo KK part. When there is talent oozing within you from an young age you are gonna be lazy. And that's what happened to Koo. But when he is on song no one matches is front court play. Well, he is a very very complacent player though. True, based on records he is not as good as LYD or CAI (who were very very good because of their great attitude) but on his day, no one matches KKK in my opinion.

iii) Goh/Tan must be one of the pairs with the fewest career achievements that won OG silver. Thats why i said earlier these former results and all don't matter that much. GVS/TWK were seriously seriously seriously good in that tournament, i should say. They were very very unlucky not to get gold. [Infact FU/Zhang were struggling in their quarters against KIM/KIM. Kim/Kim were leading the 3rd sets 11-4 and then went on to loose that game :(] Their form continued till that year end and then suddenly they are nowhere now. I feel very very sorry them as well. You can't find any flaws in their game. Be it attack, defense etc etc all bases they have covered but still they don't manage to win. :(
 
I doubt motivation is the issue. Actual natural raw talent is. Just compare Seo/Choi vs the older pairs. While there is no flaw to pick on technical wise. They don't possess the same raw talent and flair for the game as the 3 pairs that are now independent.

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk
 
i) Training with the national team doesn't necessarily have to mean that it is only fitness. Match practise, analyzing tactics of opponents using a specialized coach, not bothering about sponsor travel, so many things!! As far is fitness is concerned Ko is surely a great workhorse, as he played XD and MD simultaenously and maintained his rankings so so well.

ii) Absolutely agree on the Koo KK part. When there is talent oozing within you from an young age you are gonna be lazy. And that's what happened to Koo. But when he is on song no one matches is front court play. Well, he is a very very complacent player though. True, based on records he is not as good as LYD or CAI (who were very very good because of their great attitude) but on his day, no one matches KKK in my opinion.

iii) Goh/Tan must be one of the pairs with the fewest career achievements that won OG silver. Thats why i said earlier these former results and all don't matter that much. GVS/TWK were seriously seriously seriously good in that tournament, i should say. They were very very unlucky not to get gold. [Infact FU/Zhang were struggling in their quarters against KIM/KIM. Kim/Kim were leading the 3rd sets 11-4 and then went on to loose that game :(] Their form continued till that year end and then suddenly they are nowhere now. I feel very very sorry them as well. You can't find any flaws in their game. Be it attack, defense etc etc all bases they have covered but still they don't manage to win. :(
So you're taking the one great result from Goh/Tan over the 100 others to judge their capabilities? Statistically speaking, that's ludicrous. Personally, I'd say that was a one-off performance from them, and so far absolutely everything indicates that thats correct (they haven't won anything big since then).
How are Fu/Zhang lucky to win the Gold while Goh/Tan aren't lucky to get to the final, when they actually had been to fewer finals than even those two? I'm not saying that Fu/Zhang were a dominant pair, or that I'd rank them highly in an all-time list, but they're just as lucky or unlucky as their opponents if you're just looking at one single result.
Personally I don't rate Koo that highly - I think he was a menace on his day, but if LYD/CY/HS were on their day, they'd still beat him. The overall career achievements speak for themselves. We can't accurately judge talent, and we can't really judge how hard-working players are as outsiders. What we can compare are their results, which is really the most important thing in any athlete's career anyway, and Koo's clearly show he was not quite on the same level as those other iconic players overall.

Regarding the Ko/ntl team thing, I was only speaking about fitness - there is no reason to believe he'd be any fitter if he trained with the team. Judging by how often I've seen him with taped up achilles/calves during his time there (even icing it directly after matches) I think there actually was too much volume in their training back then. Maybe it's gotten better for the team, but as he has full control over his training schedule now, he can adjust it according to his own needs, and I think given his work ethic he is probably very close to optimal fitness under the circumstances.
BTW, national team players also participate in sponsor/PR activities, without knowing exact details I wouldn't assume he's doing any more of that now
 
So you're taking the one great result from Goh/Tan over the 100 others to judge their capabilities? Statistically speaking, that's ludicrous. Personally, I'd say that was a one-off performance from them, and so far absolutely everything indicates that thats correct (they haven't won anything big since then).
How are Fu/Zhang lucky to win the Gold while Goh/Tan aren't lucky to get to the final, when they actually had been to fewer finals than even those two? I'm not saying that Fu/Zhang were a dominant pair, or that I'd rank them highly in an all-time list, but they're just as lucky or unlucky as their opponents if you're just looking at one single result.
Personally I don't rate Koo that highly - I think he was a menace on his day, but if LYD/CY/HS were on their day, they'd still beat him. The overall career achievements speak for themselves. We can't accurately judge talent, and we can't really judge how hard-working players are as outsiders. What we can compare are their results, which is really the most important thing in any athlete's career anyway, and Koo's clearly show he was not quite on the same level as those other iconic players overall.

Regarding the Ko/ntl team thing, I was only speaking about fitness - there is no reason to believe he'd be any fitter if he trained with the team. Judging by how often I've seen him with taped up achilles/calves during his time there (even icing it directly after matches) I think there actually was too much volume in their training back then. Maybe it's gotten better for the team, but as he has full control over his training schedule now, he can adjust it according to his own needs, and I think given his work ethic he is probably very close to optimal fitness under the circumstances.
BTW, national team players also participate in sponsor/PR activities, without knowing exact details I wouldn't assume he's doing any more of that now
So you're taking the one great result from Goh/Tan over the 100 others to judge their capabilities? Statistically speaking, that's ludicrous. Personally, I'd say that was a one-off performance from them, and so far absolutely everything indicates that thats correct (they haven't won anything big since then).
How are Fu/Zhang lucky to win the Gold while Goh/Tan aren't lucky to get to the final, when they actually had been to fewer finals than even those two? I'm not saying that Fu/Zhang were a dominant pair, or that I'd rank them highly in an all-time list, but they're just as lucky or unlucky as their opponents if you're just looking at one single result.
Personally I don't rate Koo that highly - I think he was a menace on his day, but if LYD/CY/HS were on their day, they'd still beat him. The overall career achievements speak for themselves. We can't accurately judge talent, and we can't really judge how hard-working players are as outsiders. What we can compare are their results, which is really the most important thing in any athlete's career anyway, and Koo's clearly show he was not quite on the same level as those other iconic players overall.

Regarding the Ko/ntl team thing, I was only speaking about fitness - there is no reason to believe he'd be any fitter if he trained with the team. Judging by how often I've seen him with taped up achilles/calves during his time there (even icing it directly after matches) I think there actually was too much volume in their training back then. Maybe it's gotten better for the team, but as he has full control over his training schedule now, he can adjust it according to his own needs, and I think given his work ethic he is probably very close to optimal fitness under the circumstances.
BTW, national team players also participate in sponsor/PR activities, without knowing exact details I wouldn't assume he's doing any more of that now


Sorry to disagree.

i) Regarding Goh/Tan: That was not a one off performance. Perhaps it was a 1-1.5year off performance where they won Dubai super series finals etc etc. In Rio 2016, they were seriously the best pair that too by a big margin. LYD/Yoo had to struggle to compete against them. Just shows what a powerhouse they can be. Tan played absolutely brilliant in the front court. I expected them to get gold that is all. What i mentioned about Fu/Zhang was certainly related to olympics and not any other tournament.

ii) Regarding the Koo issue. Again its our personal opinion. On his day "i personally feel" KKK/TBH can outplay any pair. Only thing where Cai/LYD/HS have the advantage is their fitness levels. This is where Koo's laziness creeps in :P

iii) Regarding Ko SH. Agreed. And setting up his own schedule has also improved Ko to an extent i believe. Only thing i fear is proper match practise. With all the legends which he has played during his years even if Ko SH can mantain 80% of that intensity they would be in the top 10. (They are easily back now in the top 20).
 
Sorry to disagree.

i) Regarding Goh/Tan: That was not a one off performance. Perhaps it was a 1-1.5year off performance where they won Dubai super series finals etc etc. In Rio 2016, they were seriously the best pair that too by a big margin. LYD/Yoo had to struggle to compete against them. Just shows what a powerhouse they can be. Tan played absolutely brilliant in the front court. I expected them to get gold that is all. What i mentioned about Fu/Zhang was certainly related to olympics and not any other tournament.

ii) Regarding the Koo issue. Again its our personal opinion. On his day "i personally feel" KKK/TBH can outplay any pair. Only thing where Cai/LYD/HS have the advantage is their fitness levels. This is where Koo's laziness creeps in :p

iii) Regarding Ko SH. Agreed. And setting up his own schedule has also improved Ko to an extent i believe. Only thing i fear is proper match practise. With all the legends which he has played during his years even if Ko SH can mantain 80% of that intensity they would be in the top 10. (They are easily back now in the top 20).
Goh/Tan won the Dubai SSF because the top 3 pair that year had retired. Fu/Zhang, Lyd/Yys, Ma/Hs.

If KKK was lazy and had no stamina because he didn't want to work hard, I don't think he even deserved to be compared to the other top players who worked really hard and not relying only to skill or luck.

I am only interested in Ko/Shin, don't really care about other KOR pairs. The only legends who are still in top form is Hendra and both he and Ahsan are lucky to have great sparring partners.
 
Goh/Tan won the Dubai SSF because the top 3 pair that year had retired. Fu/Zhang, Lyd/Yys, Ma/Hs.

If KKK was lazy and had no stamina because he didn't want to work hard, I don't think he even deserved to be compared to the other top players who worked really hard and not relying only to skill or luck.

I am only interested in Ko/Shin, don't really care about other KOR pairs. The only legends who are still in top form is Hendra and both he and Ahsan are lucky to have great sparring partners.

Fair point on KKK. No one is comparing. We are just voicing our opinions out. As said before, on his day, i feel (it's a matter of my opinion) that KKK/TBH can absolutely hammer any other pairs without a fuss. That's all i claimed. People might disagree which is completely fine. Never claimed KKK was as good as CAI/LYD in terms of achievements.

Have to disagree on your second point. Hendra is not even playing anywhere near to his 50%. It's due to Ahsan's brilliance that the pair is sustaining superbly now. Ahsan has seriously stepped up in his front court and back court play.
 
Fair point on KKK. No one is comparing. We are just voicing our opinions out. As said before, on his day, i feel (it's a matter of my opinion) that KKK/TBH can absolutely hammer any other pairs without a fuss. That's all i claimed. People might disagree which is completely fine. Never claimed KKK was as good as CAI/LYD in terms of achievements.

Have to disagree on your second point. Hendra is not even playing anywhere near to his 50%. It's due to Ahsan's brilliance that the pair is sustaining superbly now. Ahsan has seriously stepped up in his front court and back court play.
I only mentioned Hendra because he is the only both OG and WC gold medalists and not to mention one of the oldest MD player in top 10.
 
Fair point on KKK. No one is comparing. We are just voicing our opinions out. As said before, on his day, i feel (it's a matter of my opinion) that KKK/TBH can absolutely hammer any other pairs without a fuss. That's all i claimed. People might disagree which is completely fine. Never claimed KKK was as good as CAI/LYD in terms of achievements.

Have to disagree on your second point. Hendra is not even playing anywhere near to his 50%. It's due to Ahsan's brilliance that the pair is sustaining superbly now. Ahsan has seriously stepped up in his front court and back court play.
But I bet @j4ckie still wouldn't rate ahsan that highly :p
 
But I bet @j4ckie still wouldn't rate ahsan that highly :p
Whether someone rates him highly or not doesn't really matter. Reality is there for anyone to see :P If you ask me to pick best player in Mens doubles now, without a doubt i would pick Ahsan. He is doing almost all the job and making the game so so easy for Setiawan.
 
But I bet @j4ckie still wouldn't rate ahsan that highly :p
Still don't. Not an all-time great for me. I actually watched some of the final and when they lose points, the majority of times it's because of him (decisions, shot quality), when they win points, it's because of Hendra the majority of times.
While there is bound to be some in balance on scoring with one player focusing on the front more, the negative aspect (losing them rallies) is constant and significant.
I am the first to say that he improved massively, seeing him play in 2011-2012 I never thought he could win a major title regardless of partners. He certainly did, and while I'm still of the opinion that Hendra is the deciding factor in that partnership, if he could carry just anyone he could've stayed with Kido and won titles, so there's no way to argue that Ahsan doesnt do his part as well.
I also happen to think he's a better player than Gideon, for example, with Gideon being a better athlete to make up for it somewhat (for now), but very limited potential past that 30-32 stage where most players start to slow down.
 
Whether someone rates him highly or not doesn't really matter. Reality is there for anyone to see If you ask me to pick best player in Mens doubles now, without a doubt i would pick Ahsan. He is doing almost all the job and making the game so so easy for Setiawan.
I'm interested in hearing any reasonable argument as to how Ahsan is better than KSS, but maybe in an appropriate thread, we've drifted far enough off topic I think. Just @ me if you ever post your rationale for this elsewhere =)
 
I'm interested in hearing any reasonable argument as to how Ahsan is better than KSS, but maybe in an appropriate thread, we've drifted far enough off topic I think. Just @ me if you ever post your rationale for this elsewhere =)
Who is KSS? True we have drifted far enough and i am sorry for that. By the way can you explain the logic behind this screenshot. Looks like BWF doesn't know how to add points :P For me points cross 56K
 

Attachments

  • 1.png
    1.png
    239.1 KB · Views: 30
Who is KSS? True we have drifted far enough and i am sorry for that. By the way can you explain the logic behind this screenshot. Looks like BWF doesn't know how to add points :p For me points cross 56K
KSS? Oh, he is a nobody. Just one half of current WR#1 and the hottest commodity in MD.

The only points added to the calculation are the ones with the red dots. So BWF did their calculation right.
 
Who is KSS? True we have drifted far enough and i am sorry for that. By the way can you explain the logic behind this screenshot. Looks like BWF doesn't know how to add points For me points cross 56K
KSS= Kevin Sanjaya Sukamuljo
Only the best 10 results count towards the world ranking, to prevent worker bee kinda players from getting inaccurately high ranking from just playing 20 tournaments
 
Back
Top