Promising Star Chen Jin Wins the Champion

[cooler]

this is where 21 pt system doesnt shine. A bad line call can cost u a point or a game in PG case even when ur serving. In the old system, a bad line call would set u back on a lost serve which one can or hope to recover and regain the serve back.

 

[cooler]

Mr Alloh, how can you criticized Chen Jin is the Fake Champion just because of you also can't sure the shuttercok is in or out?
We were on the TV screen and the linesman was on the spot, he/she who are the one can see clearly the shuttercock is in or out!
Eventhough if that point is really a misjudgment by linesman, you also can't because of this and determined Chen Jin is the Fake Champion.

In 2005 Malaysia Open, there is also some disputes about the linesman misjudgment happened during the men's single final within Lee Chong Wei and Lin Dan, so will you say Lee Chong Wei is the Fake Champion?

We as supporter or viewer, we knew that Chen Jin is played well than Peter Gade in that final game. This is the FACT but not the FAKE!!!

I am not said i am support the linesman if he/she really make a deceive on that judgment BUT we are not on the spot, we can't see clearly whether the shuttercock is in or out! That's why we can't judge people as Fake Champion because of that!

i watched that MO match lcw vs ld.
the bad line call, imo, clearly influenced LD's lost.

game 1: a bad line call, LD lost
game 2, no bad line call, LD win 2nd set
game 3., LD was way ahead of LCW point wist, then a bad line call and LD totally lost focus/interest and LCW came back took the decider.

LD was totally dominates lcw before each bad line call.

 

[KaSoon]

Ok, 1st, I am trying NOT to take any side at this moment. If ppl fellow my posts for years, they should know I am a fan for PG / Mia as well, and totally respect his/her game.

Ok, this time, PG and Mia are more on the victim side. Ok, this time, some critical line calls are more obvious than others. Ok, the match is held in CHN, and the CHN players are the winners. Ok, it might be obvious 1 or 2 line judges did get screwed in their head, and made some wrong decisions.

However...

In my previous posts, I did metion the following:

1. All the favorable (or not) calls and/or other factors are parts of the game. If you want to be the true champion, you have to be well prepared to all the issue. There's no ideal situation for everyone each single time. If you don't have strong mentality to overcome all the "unexpected", though luck.

2. Can any single pro (including our victim PG, Mia, etc) ever claim, they NEVER EVER received any favorable calls in their life time? Not even in their own nations? Of course, they did, many times could be. So, where were they when they "screw up" others? Of course, this is human nature. Once we are on the winning side, everything is ok ok, Once we lose, more or less, everyone will have a bit "taste in the mouth", and once it reached the boiling point, we blast...

3. Refer to #2, many people can argue, "but this time, the call is more obvious than others..." Well, if you make a mistake, it's a mistake. You stole $2,000,000, you are an out-law. If you ONLY stole $20, does NOT necessarily make you a better person. Therefore, a mis-judged line call of 3 inches, is not better or worse than the ones of 3mm.

4. Personally, I never encourage cheating or stuff. And I am NOT here to defend the line judges, be the mistakes are intentional or not. All I am saying is, instead of baby crying, pack the bags, go back to the gym, and train harder. If you are the true champion material, you will shine sooner or later.

Agreed & have same opinion with you points.

 

[alloh]

Any bad calls could affect the bad mood & form of Players.
That also could be the reason PG not in the game.
And I agree that CJ play well than PG in 2nd game, no doubt.!
I believe if PG in his form and against CJ which also in the form, I will pick PG is the winner. (of course at this moment, not sure later on. Coz PG is gettoing older. CJ still young)

 

[wu ming]

i watched that MO match lcw vs ld.
the bad line call, imo, clearly influenced LD's lost.

game 1: a bad line call, LD lost
game 2, no bad line call, LD win 2nd set
game 3., LD was way ahead of LCW point wist, then a bad line call and LD totally lost focus/interest and LCW came back took the decider.

LD was totally dominates???? lcw before each bad line call.

Hahahaha totally exagerated nevertheless i still respect your opinion(just alone)

 

[Fernan]

i watched the match too guys and i was disappointed with the linejudge and CJ too,he should have told the umpire that it was in,if he did that,fellow athletes and fans may have give him credit. It was so clear that the shuttle went in,you can see it at CJ's reaction,but we cannot deny the fact that CJ was well conditioned at that match. For me,PG wins the game 1 but game 2 really went CJ's way. Anyway,it will be marked in him (CJ),if he don't do anything about that cheating matter. There should be a rematch for that tournament,China Masters 2006 on the other hand,lets call CJ the China Cheat Master Champion... )