rally point - yes, 3x21 - no
Rally-piont system is better than traditional one, at least in controlling playing time. But 3x21 is not good. I think the BWF should use 5x15 (Individual) /3x15 (Team), and the decisive game, I think BWF should use 11 points, the reason is as follows:
1) more like traditional point system;
2) adding more time for advertesment; and
3) in favor of controlling playing time for team event and Qualification.
In 3x21: max - [2:1] - 21:19, 19:21 and 21:19 - 120 rallies, 60 minutes;
In 5x15: max - [3:2] - 15:13, 13:15, 15:13, 13:15 and 11:9 - 132 rallies, 66 minutes [individual];
In 3x15: max - [2:1] - 15:13, 13:15 and 11:9 - 76 rallies 38 minutes [team];
In 3x21: min - [2:0] - 21:0 and 21:0 - 42 rallies, 21 minutes;
In 5x15: min - [3:0] - 15:0, 15:0 and 15:0 - 45 rallies, 22.5 minutes [individual];
In 3x15: min - [2:0] - 15:0 and 15:0 - 30 rallies, 15 minutes [team];
In 3x21 average 81 rallies, 40.5 minutes;
In 5x15 average 88.5 rallies, 44.25 minutes [individual];
In 3x15 average 53 rallies, 26.5 minutes [team].
If a tide comes to 13:13/14:14, then the Player/pair who came to 13/14 points firstly can choose going on or adding 5/3 more points. And in the decisive tie, if the tide comes to 9:9/10:10, then the Player/pair who came to 9/10 points firstly can choose going on or adding 3/2 more points.
The BWF should use 5x15 for the individual event and 3x15 for the team event/ Qualification Individual. If the IBF uses 3x15 points.
The Sudirman Cup will spend no more than 3 hours, e.g.
XD 3x15 about 35 minutes;
MS 3x15 about 35 minutes;
WS 3x15 about 35 minutes;
MD 3x15 about 35 minutes;
WD 3x15 about 35 minutes;
total about 3 hours (max).
As for T&UC, I think the IBF should use troditional format - best of 9, and every set use 3x15, and two Cups will spend no more than 5 hours respectively, e.g.
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
total about 5 hours (max).
The play order for two cups should be as follows:
If:
Team A: singles player A, B, and C doubles a and b
Team B: singles player X, Y, and Z doubles x and y
the order is as follows:
S A-X
D a-x
S B-Y
D b-y
S C-Z
D a-y
S A-Y
D b-x
S B-X
Rally-piont system is better than traditional one, at least in controlling playing time. But 3x21 is not good. I think the BWF should use 5x15 (Individual) /3x15 (Team), and the decisive game, I think BWF should use 11 points, the reason is as follows:
1) more like traditional point system;
2) adding more time for advertesment; and
3) in favor of controlling playing time for team event and Qualification.
In 3x21: max - [2:1] - 21:19, 19:21 and 21:19 - 120 rallies, 60 minutes;
In 5x15: max - [3:2] - 15:13, 13:15, 15:13, 13:15 and 11:9 - 132 rallies, 66 minutes [individual];
In 3x15: max - [2:1] - 15:13, 13:15 and 11:9 - 76 rallies 38 minutes [team];
In 3x21: min - [2:0] - 21:0 and 21:0 - 42 rallies, 21 minutes;
In 5x15: min - [3:0] - 15:0, 15:0 and 15:0 - 45 rallies, 22.5 minutes [individual];
In 3x15: min - [2:0] - 15:0 and 15:0 - 30 rallies, 15 minutes [team];
In 3x21 average 81 rallies, 40.5 minutes;
In 5x15 average 88.5 rallies, 44.25 minutes [individual];
In 3x15 average 53 rallies, 26.5 minutes [team].
If a tide comes to 13:13/14:14, then the Player/pair who came to 13/14 points firstly can choose going on or adding 5/3 more points. And in the decisive tie, if the tide comes to 9:9/10:10, then the Player/pair who came to 9/10 points firstly can choose going on or adding 3/2 more points.
The BWF should use 5x15 for the individual event and 3x15 for the team event/ Qualification Individual. If the IBF uses 3x15 points.
The Sudirman Cup will spend no more than 3 hours, e.g.
XD 3x15 about 35 minutes;
MS 3x15 about 35 minutes;
WS 3x15 about 35 minutes;
MD 3x15 about 35 minutes;
WD 3x15 about 35 minutes;
total about 3 hours (max).
As for T&UC, I think the IBF should use troditional format - best of 9, and every set use 3x15, and two Cups will spend no more than 5 hours respectively, e.g.
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
doubles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
singles 3x15 about 35 minutes;
total about 5 hours (max).
The play order for two cups should be as follows:
If:
Team A: singles player A, B, and C doubles a and b
Team B: singles player X, Y, and Z doubles x and y
the order is as follows:
S A-X
D a-x
S B-Y
D b-y
S C-Z
D a-y
S A-Y
D b-x
S B-X
Last edited: